Why the Sutton Council Consultation Is Flawed
Sutton Council's consultation on the proposed part-closure of Browning Avenue, which would bring in a Bus Gate, is built in a way that is likely to produce skewed and biased results in favour of the scheme. Read on to see how the survey is put together and how best to respond.
The survey cannot reach a fair and balanced conclusion, because several questions are worded to steer answers toward backing the part closure. Below we look at each question and explain the problem. When you fill in the consultation, please follow the guidance on this page. Residents have also put together a balanced survey that captures both viewpoints; links to both are at the end of this page. Doing both would be ideal, but if you can only manage one, please prioritise the Council Consultation.
Question-by-Question Guidance
Question 9
This question offers a list of checkboxes covering only positive aspects. Ticking any of them could be read as saying you think the scheme is a success. There is no matching list of negative checkboxes to record the scheme's drawbacks, which makes the consultation biased.
Our recommendation: leave every option in Question 9 unticked.
Question 10
This free-text box is the only place where opposition and objections can be recorded.
Our recommendation: clearly state your objection to the scheme in Question 10.
Question 11
This question is also worded to produce results in favour of the scheme. Saying you support making streets safer, greener and so on could be read as support for these changes, while disagreeing can make you look unreasonable — which is exactly what makes it biased.
Our recommendation: select "10 = Do not support at all" so that Sutton Council cannot use the results of Question 11 as evidence of support for the scheme.
Question 12
A formal response to the statutory consultation can only be recorded if you answer "Yes" to this question.
Our recommendation: answer "Yes" to Question 12, then object wholly to the schemes when prompted on the following page.
Ready to Respond?
Use the links below to complete the Council Consultation and the residents' balanced survey.
Go to the Council Consultation Go to the Residents SurveyShare This Page
Help others find this guidance by sharing it on Twitter.
Share on TwitterEvery question in the Council survey matters, so it is worth reading the guidance for each one before you start. If you are unsure how a particular question should be answered, follow the recommendations above and record your objection clearly in the free-text box.